Wie geht’s dir?

I just read an entry on the blog Rookie Moms about joining a mother’s group and how difficult it can be to talk about all the real issues we may be having. So often, we want to demonstrate to the world that everything is fine – no post-delivery pain, sleeping babies, easy breastfeeding, etc. – as if we’re supposed to be instantly transformed into Super Mom when we give birth. We put way too much pressure on ourselves to be perfect. But how often is that really the case?

I have been fortunate enough to find a group of supportive women to go on this journey with. We met in prenatal yoga. Our instructor encouraged us to get to know each other outside of class, and it’s some of the best advice I got during pregnancy. Five of us began meeting after yoga for lunch and for walks in the park. We’d ask questions about each other’s pregnancies and check in to see if what we were experiencing was “normal.” I learned so much from these amazing women. One by one, we each gave birth to a beautiful baby boy (yup, all boys!). For over a year now, we’ve been meeting every Thursday at each other’s houses (I call it the Boys’ Club). We’ve gotten to watch each other’s boys grow from infants to toddlers. And we’ve benefited from friendships that are open enough for us to talk about everything we experience as new moms – from all the joys to all the difficulties.

I don’t know what I’d do without these incredible women. They have been my lifeline since Aleksander was born. I think there are at least two reasons we’ve been able to be so open and honest with each other. For one, we were drawn to each other as like-minded women (although we all certainly have our own ways of raising our boys!). But we all made the effort from the beginning to talk about anything and everything. Second, I think it helped that we met during pregnancy. Even before our children were born, we were engaging in pretty personal conversations. So making the transition once we became mothers wasn’t too hard.

But not everyone is so fortunate. It saddens me to think of moms out there who have to one to turn to. The author of the Rookie Moms post suggests some phrases that might help open up the channels of conversation when joining a mothers group. Things like, “This is hard to talk about …” or “I’m embarrassed to say this …”. These openers could be really helpful to talk about the difficult issues we face as new (or even experienced) mothers. Still, while these phrases help open the door, they can still take quite a lot of courage to initiate. Wouldn’t it be nice of the women in a mom’s group asked each other how things were going … and really meant it?

When I was studying in Germany as a grad student, my friends and I used to meet at our favorite pub on Friday nights. Over a beer, we’d ask each other “Wie geht’s dir?” In German, that means “how are you?” or “how’s it going?” For an American this question is taken rather lightly. The conversation goes something like: “How are you?” – “Fine, thanks, how are you?” – “Fine.” – and the two people go their separate ways. In Germany, the question is only asked if one wants a real answer. So even though my friends were also American, we asked the question in the German manner: Wie geht’s dir? It was great. We all had an opportunity to talk about our frustrations and difficulties at the university or in the culture or whatever.

So next time you’re at a mom’s group, try asking one of the other moms, “How are you? Really. How are you?” (You don’t have to do it in German!)

Question: Do you have other moms you can really talk to?


3 Comments (+add yours?)

  1. RookieMom Whitney
    Jan 27, 2011 @ 15:41:54

    I love this. Thanks for sharing. My mom’s group is fantastic. Our kids are 6 and we still go out to dinner once per month. We have all had second children now and as each person went through that, we helped remind each other what we had learned collectively the first time around.

    Isn’t it funny that “how are you?” means different things depending on how, when, and to whom it is asked?!


  2. KateR
    Jan 27, 2011 @ 17:38:23

    Thanks so much for checking out my blog and leaving a comment, Whitney! I’m just getting started, so I appreciate any feedback 🙂
    It’s also great to hear of another successful mothers’ group and that it continues with the second kids and beyond. Fabulous!


  3. RookieMom Heather
    Jan 28, 2011 @ 12:46:25

    I like this post and wish my mom’s group experience had gone as well. Though we really helped each other through something significant, we never had the stamina to keep it up.

    Just yesterday, I had lunch with an old friend and she asked how I was… I had to pause a second and ask, “wait do you want the real answer or the short answer?”


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: